Effects of audit committee and fiscal council on earnings quality in Brazil
Name: VITOR GOMES BAIOCO
Publication date: 20/05/2015
Advisor:
Name![]() |
Role |
---|---|
JOSE ELIAS FERES DE ALMEIDA | Advisor * |
Examining board:
Name![]() |
Role |
---|---|
JOSE ELIAS FERES DE ALMEIDA | Advisor * |
PATRÍCIA MARIA BORTOLON | Internal Examiner * |
Summary: This dissertation was developed in order to investigate the installation and characteristics
effects of the Fiscal Council and the Audit Committee on the quality of accounting
information in Brazil. The characteristics studied were independence and qualification of
members. The proxies for accounting information quality were value relevance, timeliness
and conditional conservatism. The sample was composed by Brazilian companies listed on
the Securities, Commodities, and Futures Exchange (BM&FBovespa), with annual liquidity
over 0,001 in the period of years 2010 to 2013. The data were collected from Comdinheiro
database and Reference Forms, available on the website of the CVM or BM&FBovespa. The
information models were adapted to the methodological approach and estimated by the
method of ordinary least squares (OLS) with robust standard errors clustered by firm. The
results revealed the purpose of installation of the institutions analyzed on the proxies of
accounting information quality. The installation of the Fiscal Council positively impacted the
relevance of net equity, while the installation of the Audit Committee impacted the relevance
of earnings. These results may indicate differences in the attention of these institutions: to
protect the organizations equity for shareholders (Fiscal Council) or to ensure more trusted
numbers on the managers performance (Audit Committee). In parallel, the results for the
installation of Permanent Fiscal Council has inferred strength of this institution as control
mechanism, rather than the installer only at the request of the shareholders. However, the
implementation of Powered Fiscal Council was inefficient in controlling of the accounting
information quality. In the characteristics analysis, the Audit Committee members
independence impacted the relevance of earnings. While the Fiscal Council members
independence impacted the relevance of net equity and impacted the conditional conservatism
(timely recognition of economic losses). These associations were more significant when the
Fiscal Council members were independent of the controlling shareholders. In the members
qualification analysis, were found positive evidences between the relevance of net equity and
a higher proportion of Council Fiscal members with qualification in Business (Accounting,
Administration and Economy). The conditional conservatism was higher when the Fiscal
Council members qualification converged to Accounting. The results of the Audit Committee
members qualification demonstrated relevance of earnings in the presence of at least one
Accountant, and at higher proportion of members with qualification in both Accounting and
Business; being more significant when the Audit Committee members qualification
converged to Accounting.